Short answer: Anything you type about your case into a free or public AI tool like ChatGPT may not be private. Some courts have said those conversations are not protected by attorney-client privilege, and some have limited how parties can use AI with case documents. Until the law settles, keep your case details out of public AI tools and bring your questions to your attorney.
Many people now use AI tools to research legal problems, organize their thoughts, or draft notes. That makes sense. These tools are fast, free, and easy to use. But courts have started ruling on what happens to that information once a lawsuit begins, and some of those rulings are a real problem for those that find themselves in a law suit.
What Courts Have Ruled So Far
Your AI chats may not be protected by attorney-client privilege
In United States v. Heppner (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 17, 2026), a federal court in New York ruled that a defendant's written exchanges with a public AI platform were not protected by attorney-client privilege. The court said an AI tool is not a lawyer, so no attorney-client relationship existed. It also pointed to the platform's privacy policy, which allowed the company to use inputs for AI training and share data with third parties. Because of that, the court said the user had no reasonable expectation that his conversations would stay confidential.
Sending your AI research to your lawyer afterward does not fix it
In the same case, the court ruled the work product doctrine did not apply either. The defendant used the AI tool on his own, not at his lawyer's direction. The court rejected the idea that independent research becomes protected just because it is later shared with an attorney.
Some courts have protected AI-assisted work
Other courts have reached a different result in civil cases:
- In Warner v. Gilbarco, Inc. (E.D. Mich. Feb. 10, 2026), the court refused to force a self-represented plaintiff to turn over her AI use. It said AI programs are "tools, not persons," and using one is not the same as disclosing your work to the other side.
- In Morgan v. V2X, Inc. (D. Colo. Mar. 30, 2026), the court agreed that a party's own litigation preparation is protected in a civil case, even without a lawyer involved.
You may still have to disclose which AI tool you used
In Morgan, the court protected the content of the plaintiff's AI work but ordered him to name the AI tool. He had already entered confidential case information into it, and the court said the other side was entitled to know where that information went.
Courts are limiting AI use with case documents
- In Morgan, the court barred the parties from putting confidential information into AI tools unless the provider is contractually prohibited from training on the data and sharing it, and must delete it on request. The court acknowledged this rules out most free and low-cost AI tools.
- In Jeffries v. Harcros Chemicals Inc. (D. Kan. Mar. 25, 2026), the court went further and banned public AI tools for all documents and information exchanged in discovery, whether or not they were marked confidential. The court noted that once data is fed into a public AI tool, it is practically impossible to pull it back.
Do These Rulings Apply in Florida?
These are federal trial court decisions from other states. They do not bind Florida courts. But they show how judges are thinking about AI, and Florida judges can and do look to decisions like these when a new issue comes up. Courts may also enter protective orders in any case that restrict how parties use AI, and violating a court order can lead to sanctions.
What This Means for You
- Don't put details about your case into free or public AI tools. That includes facts, documents, emails, settlement numbers, and your thoughts on strategy.
- Assume anything you type into a public AI tool could be seen by the other side.
- If you've already used AI on your case, tell your attorney. Your lawyer needs to know what you entered and which tool you used so it can be addressed early.
- Never put documents from the other side into an AI tool without checking with your attorney first. A protective order in your case may forbid it.
- Bring your questions to your lawyer. Conversations with your attorney are protected. Conversations with a chatbot may not be.
- Don't put your lawyers communications into AI. Conversations with your attorney are protected. Sharing them with a third
Frequently Asked Questions
Are my ChatGPT conversations about my case confidential?
Not necessarily. At least one federal court has ruled that conversations with a public AI platform are not protected by attorney-client privilege, in part because the platform's privacy policy allowed it to use and share what users typed.
If I send my AI research to my lawyer, does it become privileged?
Not automatically. In United States v. Heppner, the court ruled that research a person did on their own with an AI tool did not become protected just because it was later shared with an attorney.
Can the other side find out which AI tool I used?
Possibly. In Morgan v. V2X, Inc., the court required a party to disclose the name of the AI tool he used because he had already entered confidential case information into it.
Can I upload documents from my lawsuit into an AI tool?
Check with your attorney first. Some courts have barred parties from putting confidential case documents into public AI tools, and one court banned public AI tools for all documents exchanged in discovery.
Do these rulings apply to cases in Florida?
They are federal decisions from outside Florida and are not binding on Florida courts. They do show where courts are heading, and a court in any case can restrict AI use through a protective order.
The Bottom Line
The law on AI and legal privilege is changing quickly, and courts don't agree yet. The safest course is to keep your case out of public AI tools and talk to your attorney before using AI for anything related to your lawsuit.
If you are involved in a lawsuit or expect one, contact Dunivan Law to schedule a consultation. Call 813.252.0239 or visit dunivanlaw.com.
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.